post

What Schools Should Include in Teaching Job Ads to Reduce Unqualified Applications

Schools should include teaching job ad requirements such as registration status, accredited qualifications, subject specialisation, and clear selection criteria. When an ad states these plainly, ineligible candidates rule themselves out before they apply. Your panel then reads fewer applications, and more of them fit the role.

That filtering only works when the details sit in the ad itself rather than in an attached position description. Francis Orr supports Australian schools with teacher recruitment, and buried requirements are easy for a busy candidate to skim past.

This guide covers why vague ads backfire, the five requirements every teaching ad needs, and how to write selection criteria that sort applicants. You’ll also see which application steps screen out casual applicants.

Read on before your next role goes live.

Why Do Vague School Job Advertisements Attract So Many Unqualified Applicants?

A school principal at their desk on a Monday morning

Vague school job ads often attract unsuitable applicants because they don’t explain the requirements clearly. After all, a phrase like “passionate educator wanted” could describe almost any teacher, so readers have little reason to decide the role isn’t right for them.

Large job boards make that problem worse. Candidates can apply to many roles in one sitting, and a one-click button costs them nothing (apart from a few seconds spent scrolling past the ad). If your ad skips registration or subject details, an unregistered graduate may send a CV anyway.

Each unsuitable application then adds to the leadership team’s workload. Someone still needs to review the CV, assess the candidate, and send a polite rejection. During a busy school term, these extra tasks take time away from reports and other responsibilities. If you’ve ever spent a Sunday arvo sorting through CVs for one English teaching position, you’ll know how quickly the work can pile up.

Including specific requirements helps candidates assess their suitability before applying. This encourages people who don’t meet the criteria to rule themselves out, giving your team more time to focus on qualified applicants. It’s a practical first step towards a clearer school hiring process.

Teaching Position Requirements: The Non-Negotiables Every Ad Needs

A single sentence about teacher registration can remove many of the applications you’d otherwise read. When we talk with principals about hiring, they tell us the same thing: these legal and practical gates decide eligibility before any interview does. Each requirement below belongs near the top of the ad rather than in a PDF.

Current Teacher Registration With Your State or Territory Authority

Teachers must hold registration to legally teach in Australian schools, although the requirements vary by state and territory. For example, teachers in Queensland must register with the Queensland College of Teachers (QCT) before they can work in a school. Other states have their own registration authorities, such as NESA in New South Wales.

These requirements give schools a clear way to screen applicants before reviewing their CVs. Name the relevant registration authority in your job ad and state whether provisional registration is acceptable.

You should also ask applicants to provide their registration number so your office can verify their status before shortlisting.

An Accredited Initial Teacher Education Qualification

Teacher registration usually requires an accredited initial teacher education (ITE) qualification, such as a Bachelor of Education or Master of Teaching. For overseas-trained teachers, the process may also involve an AITSL (Australian Institute for Teaching and School Leadership) assessment to confirm that their qualifications meet Australian standards.

Since applicants may hold different types of qualifications, your job ad should explain exactly what the school accepts. A line such as “accredited ITE qualification or AITSL-assessed equivalent” makes the requirement clear and helps unsuitable candidates rule themselves out. When reviewing applications, also check qualifications against registration records rather than relying on CVs alone.

A Valid Working With Children Check Before Day One

Each state has its own screening process for people who work with children, and staff must complete the required check before starting work. In NSW, this is called a Working with Children Check, while Queensland uses a blue card.

Your job ad should state that applicants need a current check by their start date. This gives anyone who needs to apply time to complete the process (as processing times vary between states). Add the check to your pre-employment checklist too, so you can catch expired cards before sending out contracts.

The Exact Subject Areas and Year Levels You Need Covered

A general “secondary teacher” ad can attract applicants from many subject areas, even if the school needs someone with specific teaching skills. To attract suitable candidates, name the learning areas, year levels and senior subjects required, such as VCE Chemistry or HSC Mathematics Extension 1.

These details help teachers decide if their experience matches the role. For instance, someone qualified to teach senior physics will recognise that “Years 11 and 12 physics” suits their background. You should also mention any preferred second teaching area, as this gives you another way to compare candidates with similar experience.

Work Rights in Australia and Any Visa Sponsorship Position

Visa requirements can affect a candidate’s eligibility, sometimes late in the recruitment process. Your job ad should explain whether the school offers visa sponsorship or requires applicants to have full Australian work rights. This helps overseas applicants check if they can accept the role before preparing an application.

Being clear about these requirements also saves your panel from interviewing candidates who can’t work in the position. If the school offers sponsorship, name the visa type so applicants can check their eligibility before applying.

A teacher's hand pointing to the registration number

Writing Teacher Selection Criteria That Filter Rather Than Flatter

Once the necessary legal requirements are clear, your selection criteria help identify the most suitable candidates. However, vague phrases such as “excellent communication skills” do little to narrow the field because almost every applicant will claim to have them.

Strong criteria ask candidates to provide evidence of specific skills and experience. In our experience placing teachers, the most useful criteria describe a task, the context and the expected result. A criterion such as “Evidence of planning Year 9 science units aligned with the Australian Curriculum” tells applicants exactly what experience the school expects. Candidates without that experience can recognise the gap before applying.

Keep the list short as well. A few specific criteria make it easier to compare applicants and help teachers understand the requirements without spending hours on their application. It also keeps your teaching job ad requirements easy to scan.

Run each draft criterion through these tests before it goes in the ad:

  • Does it name a specific year level, subject or program?
  • Can the applicant prove it with an example from their own teaching?
  • Would a weak candidate struggle to claim it honestly?
  • Can your panel score it in an interview?
  • Does it link back to the duties in the teacher job description?

Rewrite any criterion that fails two of these tests. The ones that pass can then become your interview scoring guide, so the ad and the interview measure the same things.

The Application Process Itself Does Half the Screening

Sharp criteria tell people what you want, and the way they apply adds a second filter. A school job advertisement asking for written responses tends to draw fewer speculative applications than one with a single upload button. These process details keep casual applicants from clicking apply:

  • Written Criteria Responses: Short written answers show who read the ad. The NSW selection criteria guidelines from the NSW Department of Education (2026) cap responses at half an A4 page per criterion. Copy a limit like that so applicants see the effort upfront.
  • Required Documents List: Registration numbers, a current check, and two referees belong on a clear checklist. Incomplete applications then stand out at a glance, so state that you won’t assess them.
  • A Named Contact Person: Listing a staff member for questions lets unsure applicants test their fit before writing anything. Give a phone number and email rather than a generic inbox.

These requirements ask applicants to put some thought and effort into their applications. As a result, your panel can focus on candidates who have read the ad, provided the requested information, and followed the instructions.

A young graduate sitting on a living room sofa in bright natural

Rewrite Your Next Teaching Ad Before It Goes Live

Schools cut unqualified applications by stating registration, qualifications, and selection criteria plainly in the ad. Ineligible candidates then rule themselves out before they apply, and your shortlist starts stronger.

Before your next role goes live, check the ad against the five non-negotiables and the criteria tests above. Then cut any line that could describe every teacher in the country.

Francis Orr offers recruitment guidance for Australian schools hiring qualified teaching staff. Contact us to review your next teaching ad and build a shortlist you can interview with confidence.